New Roommate Always There

CHICAGO, IL—Marquette University grad and now local tenant in Lincoln Park, Loren Smithe, 23, is growing increasingly bewildered and annoyed by roommate Joshway DeWitt’s constant presence in their apartment, Smithe reported Tuesday.
DeWitt eats breakfast in the living room almost every morning (have I ever mentioned the dishes?).
"It's like the guy never leaves," Smithe said.
Whether silently eating his cereal, looking out the window, talking to himself, or reading a book while standing up, DeWitt's quiet and unvaried living habits have managed to "unnerve" Smithe.
"The other night I was in the living room watching TV and he came out of nowhere and sat right next to me without saying a word," Smithe said, wondering what DeWitt's deal was. "He just sat there for 45 minutes, watching what I was watching, until I finally got up and left."
The two have lived together since last summer, when DeWitt responded to Smithe's "Roommate Wanted" ad on Craigslist. Smithe said that she regretted not being more specific about the type of person she was looking for, having chosen instead to highlight the apartment's "awesome patio."
"Even when he came over to check the apartment out, he kind of puttered around, opening and closing the silverware drawer, and peeking in closets," Smithe said. "Looking back, all the signs were there."
Smithe said her past roommates had been conspicuously mobile, frequently leaving the house and returning with fresh groceries, obvious suntans, and recently met men. But DeWitt has exhibited no discernible interest in the world beyond his living quarters, instead spending hours in the apartment's common areas surfing myspace or talking to himself.
Smithe claimed that, on the rare occasion that her roommate retreats to his bedroom, DeWitt leaves the door wide open (it’s only dead-bolted with the rare occasion party), even while asleep.
"I can't get away from him," Smithe said.
Adding to Smithe's frustration, DeWitt has paid rent and utility bills on time without fail.
"He's got an income coming from somewhere," said Smithe, who last week increased her hours by volunteering in order to avoid DeWitt's evening routine of aimless pacing and off-key whistling. "But I don't know where it comes from—he never leaves to go to a job."
Smithe said the situation reached a "critical mass" when she returned from a weekend trip to find Joe, a creationsist from Oklahoma, interested in subletting DeWitt’s room.
"I felt like I'd stepped through a wormhole," Smithe said. "Everything was exactly the same. Same shit new day."
Some clues seem to indicate DeWitt engages in a relatively normal level of day-to-day activity, among them, changes in facial hair, many boxes of half-eaten thai carry-out, and a jar of peanut butter belonging to DeWitt that slowly emptied until it was replaced in the first week of June.
Although she briefly considered subletting, Smithe said she wouldn’t know where to go, she will most likely finish out her current lease with DeWitt and eventually move into a modest two-bedroom loft with her exquisite friend, Renae, where she hopes to "finally get some normalcy."
When asked for comment on Smithe's allegations, DeWitt expressed confusion and walked away...
"He's a complete mystery to me. That girl’s, like, never here," DeWitt said.